When it comes to anything baby/kids, there is sure to be debate. Whether it's baby wearing, homemade food, shots, circumcision, bed sharing, pacies, Santa, crying-it-out, or a myriad of other things, there is sure to be at least someone saying one thing, and another saying the opposite - both believing they are right.
Luckily,
I know what's right about all these things, so I don't need to engage anyone in these debates, and Damon and I are used to bucking the "What to Expect..." trends in many things we've done. I'm sure, after I write this post, that there will be readers who disagree with us yet again. And what am I writing about today?
Starting solids.
Obviously, there are many opinions about when to introduce a baby to something other than breast milk/formula. When to do it, what to try first...blah blah blah.
Personally, we are in the camp of "no need to start baby on solids at the first possible moment most pediatricians give the nod." Usually that's around 4 months. It's funny how
not starting a baby at that early point is considered by most as "waiting." As if starting solids at 4 months is the norm, and if you don't, you are delaying.
We understand that babies get all they need from Mommie's milk and they can survive quite well on just that for their first year. But, obviously, formula is not breast milk's equal. And, interestingly, Damon and I differ a bit on the exact timing of when to start solids. I think he said "eight months" was when he thought we should start. I don't think that was exactly my first impulse. Wait - yes. But how long? 6 months? 8 months? 1 year?
We've bantered back and forth on the issue. We started Kestian and Adelaide on solids around 6 1/2 months, but breast milk supply at that point was dwindling. It was that or formula.


By introducing solids then, we managed to stave off formula until 10 months.
But Fenton is a whole different situation. Full term. Formula fed. We can't so much compare the two. Still, I don't think I'm crazy about waiting until 8 months - and probably
because he is on formula is why I don't want to wait that long, as this piece from
this article article indicates:
"the four month recommendation applies more to formula fed infants, and the six month recommendation applies more to breastfed infants."..."Formula is not as complete a food as breast milk, and formula fed babies are more likely to become anemic than babies who are breastfed, so they need iron-enriched food earlier."
But still, when?
Damon says: Why start now? I say: Why wait anymore? There is a lot of information (such as
here) pointing to waiting until 6 months to lessen the chance of allergies, to make sure the baby's digestive tract is mature, etc. etc. So I am happy to wait past 6 months. But I am hard-pressed to find anything that shows waiting until 8 months, 10 months, a year with a formula fed baby is advantageous. Sure, I'm not going to force it on Fenton, but since he is on the lesser-than-best food, and he is growing way faster than K and A were at this age, it is good to wait anymore? Is he missing out on iron that he should be getting? Should I not allow him to try?
So after Fenton's recent checkup with our pediatrician, where he is now:
18 lbs 3 oz (55 percentile)
28.75 inches (96 percentile)
we discussed starting solids. He's 6 1/2 months old now, and the doc (according to Damon, because I was at work) said we could keep waiting. But, still it begs the question,
should we keep waiting?
Ultimately, it will be up to Fenton. Damon says it's OK with him to try it, and I think Fenton is ready, but does Fenton?
So here's my first attempt at trying some cereal:
Dry run: Trying out the chair.
First bite. Very dubious!
Ummm...no thanks!

These spoons are cool though...
Yes...I'll eat the spoons...
Damon's "I told you so look" aside, I could see that Fenton wasn't very excited about it all. But still, does that mean he's not ready? Does that mean we should wait more? Or maybe he was full from an earlier bottle. Or maybe he was reacting to the new texture. Or maybe rice cereal just sucks. What's not to say that no matter when we tried it (now or at 8 months), he wouldn't do the same thing, ready or not? After all, I don't remember Kestian and Adelaide exactly inhaling their first bowl of cereal. It was actually pretty anticlimactic as well.
So, maybe he's ready. Maybe he's not. I'll try again in a few days...