Ok. So I know I haven't talked about this whole VBAC thing very much (sarcasm, people) but as we get closer and closer to the big day (4 more months!) and I read more and more about it, I just feel the need to share. Well, not really share, more like vent. After all, this is a multi-purpose blog. I share stories about the kids, have heated debates with myself about various issues, and often just blather on about what-not. Hopefully some of it is entertaining/educational/useful/familiar/humorous etc to someone else.
And I guess it's the shock and awe of finding out that you can't just walk into a doctor's office and declare "I don't want another c-section" and everyone happily avails themselves to your VBAC whim.
No it's not like that at all. So I guess I keep writing about it because as I learn more and more about VBACs and the controversy surrounding them, as I read about other
women going through the same thing, and perhaps because I feel that at least on occasion I should put my bachelor's of community health education degree to use and try to educate at least one other person on the situation, that I keep on keepin' on.
So yes, in today's edition of the blog, we again focus ourselves on VBACs. Quick quiz - what does VBAC stand for?
- Very Big And Catlike
- Voodoo Battle Against Cows
- Victory Begins At Chernobyl
Well if you guessed any of the above, we need to talk. But seriously, as I was looking for a reader-friendly description of VBAC, I found
this one on wikipedia. I think it states the controversy quite well (surprisingly) and if you at least read this you can get an idea about what the "problem" is. In fact, I find it quite interesting that it cites some of the resources I have been reviewing as I try to learn more about all of this (
ICAN,
VBACfacts.com,
VBAC.com).
So basically it seems to boil down to this: Doctors/hospitals are afraid that for a woman who has had a previous c-section, her uterus will rupture during labor, killing the mother and baby. To avoid this disastrous consequence: they push for another c-section.
Yes, I think that about sums it up. And, yes that sounds quite scary, and so therefore the solution seems quite reasonable. But let take a minute and look at a few things. Join me, will you?
Ok. First, let's take this quote:
“the chance that a VBAC candidate will require emergency surgery is, for all practical purposes, no higher than that of any other pregnant woman” and “the risk of VBAC is not substantially greater than the risk of any type of childbirth."
- Bruce Flamm, MD, author of
Birth After Cesarean: The Medical FactsGood. We're getting somewhere already. Women who want VBACs aren't at any more risk for needing surgery. You have to ask, then, why do doctors keep pushing this?
But what about this whole uterine rupture thing that keeps getting waived around, scaring women? Let's look at that rate, and also compare it to other risks (which I think really puts it into perspective). I've taken the following from
http://www.pregnancybirthandbabies.com/vbac.htmThe concept of uterine rupture is scary. It certainly is a risk to be considered when thinking about a VBAC. However it is important to note that nothing is with out risk.
Lets say the risk of uterine rupture is 0.19-0.8% with a low transverse incision.
- The risk of miscarriage after amniocentesis is 0.5 to 1% (a procedure offered routinely to many women)
- The risk of a cesarean delivery following induction is 5.9 to 11.9%
- The risk of hysterectomy after an elective cesarean is 0.2%
- The risk of long term affects from an epidural are:
- Backache 19%
- Frequent headaches 4.6%
- Migraines 1.9%
- The risk of fever with an epidural is 15%
- The risk of developing gestational diabetes is 7%
- The risk of a hypertensive disorder (high blood pressure and related issues) in pregnancy is 5-10%
- The risk for preterm birth is 12%
The point of this is not to be doom and gloom. The point is that uterine rupture needs to be put into perspective, that the risk is not an outlandishly high number, when in fact, the risk is very low when proper screening and proper precautions are taken. "
Ok. Better now? Now see? There are so many other things that we can worry about. Let's put our energy elsewhere.
I could go on and on about all the complications one faces from a c-section both immediate and long-term (that doctors really just don't discuss), about how your risk for future successful pregnancies and vaginal deliveries goes down with every c-section you have, about how the risks of infection and infertility go up with every c-section, but I have to save
something for another post. And don't get me wrong, if a medical emergency calls for a c-section to save my life or my baby's life, then by all means cut away. But, rather, what I seem to face is a c-section "on the table" and I have to justify why not to automatically go that route, when in reality a natural birth should be the assumption with a c-section only put on the table as a medical crisis requires it. I mean, wouldn't you agree?
And so I recently had another appt with my OB, and I had all my
questions ready to ask him, only to find him called away to the hospital (again). I'll tell you, it gets old when you keep going to see your doctor and he's never there to talk to. Maybe that's just me though.
Meanwhile...(dramatic music please)... two of my friends - friends who don't know each other (at least I think they don't know each other...Karen, do you know Deborah? Deborah, do you know Karen?) recommended to me a midwife that works with women wanting VBACs. So I have gone ahead and made an appointment with her. Again, if you need a refresher on what a midwife does, please check
here. I'm actually very excited about meeting with this midwife and asking her the same questions I have for my OB. When everyone answers them, and I compare what I find, I think the outcome will be obvious.
For those of you wanting further reading on this issue, you can refer to the above websites, watch "The Business of Being Born" and just do some Google searches. It is way more fascinating than you can imagine. And from what I have read, I know in addition to not wanting another c-section, I don't want to be induced, to have an epidural, or basically any type of intervention short of a
true medical emergency.
But that's the trick, isn't it? Knowing just when something is a true medical emergency verses the doctors/hospitals covering their asses. Thankfully, I have a wonderfully educated and logical thinking husband who doesn't take "shit" from anyone and a doula (yet to be hired) with tons of experience in this. It's as prepared as I can be.